Chapter 2: Shadows Behind the Plaster

#content-1

I pressed myself against the far wall, my breath held tight in my chest. Arthur stood, unmoving, his back to the private library. He was looking directly at the heavy oak wardrobe, or rather, at the plaster wall just behind it.

The silence in the grand room felt impossibly loud. My own heart hammered against my ribs, a frantic drumbeat I was sure he could hear through the thin barrier.

He took a slow step forward.

Then another.

His polished shoe scraped faintly on the Persian rug. Each sound was amplified in my small room, a warning bell. My eyes fixed on the small gap, the sliver of light from the library growing wider as he approached.

Arthur reached the wardrobe. His fingers, heavy with a gold signet ring, tapped once, then twice, against the old wood.

“Drafty old house,” he grumbled, his voice low, a dry rumble I could barely make out. “Always something.”

He turned to Garrett Holbrook, who still sat at the bidding table, his head slightly bowed.

“The foundations settle, Holbrook. It’s a constant battle.”

Holbrook nodded, not meeting his eyes. “Indeed, Mr. Danforth. Especially with such age.”

Arthur gave the wardrobe one last dismissive glance, then walked back to the bidding table, settling into his high-backed chair. He picked up a small gavel, his face composed once more.

The auction continued, the silent bids resuming, but I barely registered it. The immediate danger had passed, yet a new, colder dread was settling in.

I crept back to my cot, the worn springs groaning beneath my weight. My eyes scanned my tiny room, the peeling wallpaper, the single grimy window looking out onto a narrow alley. The $450 rent had been a miracle when I’d found it on Craigslist. A miracle that was starting to feel like a cruel joke.

Arthur’s words about “old houses” echoed. My family had owned this brownstone for generations. Not just *a* brownstone on the Upper East Side. *This* brownstone. My grandparents had lived here. My parents.

My mind raced, piecing together fragments I hadn’t thought about in years. The layout of the old house. The “servant’s quarters” tucked away in the back, accessed by a separate staircase, with smaller rooms and its own entrance from the alley.

My heart seized. This wasn’t just a random cheap sublet in a rich neighborhood. This was it. This was the back wing of the Danforth ancestral home, the very brownstone Arthur now controlled.

The one I used to play in as a child, before my parents’ trust funds disappeared into Arthur’s schemes, before my own life crashed.

A wave of nausea washed over me. The low rent, the anonymous listing – it was all deliberate. Arthur had put this room up for lease through some shell company, knowing full well who might be desperate enough to take it. He was watching. Or, he wanted to be watched.

My gaze drifted back to the small hole behind the wardrobe. It wasn’t rough or recently made. The edges were smoothed, almost polished by time. It was old. Much older than my bankruptcy. Older than Arthur’s current schemes.

A sudden, sharp memory cut through the haze. My grandmother, her voice hushed, complaining about Arthur even as a teenager. He was always “too curious,” always “poking into things.” He’d wanted to know what everyone was doing, what they were hiding.

He’d wanted to know *everything*.

The hole wasn’t for me to spy on Arthur. It was Arthur’s hole. He’d cut it decades ago, a teenage voyeur, to spy on the family living here. He’d carved it out to listen to arguments, to secrets, to everything that happened in the main library.

It wasn’t a coincidence that I had found it. It was a cold, hard secret that had been hidden right here, waiting for someone to rediscover it.

Arthur wasn’t worried about a draft. He was just checking on his old, private peephole.

You May Also Like

More From Author

+ There are no comments

Add yours