The empty photo frame still haunted my thoughts, a silent accusation that echoed Brenda’s carefully placed doubts. I’d spent sleepless nights replaying every interaction, every dismissed memory. Was she right? Was I truly losing my grip? But a new, far colder suspicion was about to replace my self-doubt, one that had nothing to do with forgotten conversations.
“Sarah, can you help me find the glue stick?” Leo Holloway asked, his small voice pulling me back to the present.
He sat cross-legged on the floor of his sun-drenched playroom, surrounded by cardboard cutouts of jungle animals for his school diorama. Brenda had asked me to watch him for the afternoon while she ran errands, a perfectly normal request from a “friend.”
I smiled, pushing away the lingering unease that often settled when I was in Brenda’s house.
“Of course, buddy. Let’s look under here.”
I knelt beside him, rummaging through a box overflowing with craft supplies: glitter, pipe cleaners, construction paper in every color. Leo, meanwhile, excitedly pointed to a small elephant.
“This one is for the watering hole! And the giraffe will eat the tall leaves.”
As he lifted a cardboard giraffe, his sleeve rode up his arm, revealing his inner wrist. My breath hitched.
There, just below the delicate blue veins of his skin, was a distinctive birthmark. It was small, roughly the size of a pea, and shaped like a tiny, imperfect star.
A jolt of memory, sharp and unexpected, ran through me. It wasn’t about misplaced keys or phantom conversations. This was visual, concrete.
I remembered that mark.
Years ago, before I’d moved to Spring Lake, before Brenda Holloway was anything more than a name in my new neighborhood’s welcome packet, I’d been scrolling through old social media posts. I’d been trying to get a feel for the local community, looking at profiles linked to the Spring Lake neighborhood group.
Brenda’s profile had popped up. Among her carefully curated photos of family vacations and perfect holiday meals, there had been one blurry, candid shot from years prior. It showed a group of young adults at a backyard barbecue. One of them, a lanky young man with a rebellious glint in his eye, had his arm thrown over someone else’s shoulder. His sleeve was slightly pushed up.
And there it was.
The same distinctive, almost star-shaped birthmark on his inner wrist.
The caption beneath the old photo had casually mentioned “Cousin Dave’s fleeting visit.” Brenda had commented on it, something dismissive about her “wild cousin David Sullivan” who “never settled down.” I’d barely registered it at the time, just another face in a sea of new acquaintances. Now, it slammed into me with the force of a physical blow.
Leo, here, now. David Sullivan, years ago, in a faded photograph. The birthmark was too specific, too unique to be a coincidence.
My heart began to pound a frantic rhythm against my ribs. This wasn’t gaslighting. This was something else entirely. This was a secret, hidden in plain sight on an innocent child.
I forced myself to speak, my voice coming out a little too high.
“That’s a neat birthmark, Leo. I haven’t noticed it before.”
Leo barely glanced at it, focused on his crafting.
“Oh, yeah! Mommy says I got it from her side of the family. Grandpa Holloway has one on his back, but mine is smaller.”
My mind raced. From Brenda’s side. Not Mark’s. That was a small detail, easily dismissed, but now, it felt like a tiny crack in Brenda’s flawless facade.
I watched Leo, a bright, curious eight-year-old, entirely oblivious to the seismic shift happening in my perception of his world. He was just a kid, building a jungle. I was an adult, suddenly seeing the carefully constructed walls around him.
“You know, I think I remember seeing a picture of your Cousin Dave once,” I said, trying to sound casual, my fingers still sifting through glitter. “Is he still around? I don’t think I’ve ever met him at any of the family gatherings.”
Leo shrugged, sticking an orange paper tiger onto a cardboard tree.
“I don’t know. I’ve never met him. Mommy says he travels a lot. He’s super wild.”
Super wild. That’s what Brenda had said in the old photo caption. The same words.
The image of Cousin Dave, with that same birthmark, flashed through my mind again. He hadn’t just been “wild”; the online chatter around that old photo, vague as it was, had hinted at a brief period of disruption, a ripple in the calm waters of Spring Lake society before he’d vanished as quickly as he’d appeared.
I spent the rest of the afternoon in Leo’s playroom, mechanically helping him glue felt leaves and paint cardboard rocks, while my thoughts churned. The gaslighting, the small, unsettling incidents—they had made me doubt myself. They had made me feel isolated, crazy even. But this? This was a physical fact. A biological marker that pointed to a specific person, a person Brenda kept at a distinct remove.
My phone vibrated with a text from Brenda: “On my way back, thanks for watching Leo!”
I typed a quick, “No problem, he’s a joy!” before setting my phone down.
As soon as Brenda walked through the door, all smiles and apologies for running late, I watched her with a new, unsettling clarity. She didn’t just smile with her mouth; her eyes, usually so warm and inviting, now seemed to hold a flicker of something guarded, something I hadn’t noticed before.
“Everything alright, Sarah? You look a little… thoughtful,” Brenda said, her gaze sharp.
I managed a strained smile. “Just tired. Leo has so much energy! We finished his diorama, though.”
“Oh, you’re the best, Sarah! He usually leaves these things to the last minute.” She gave my arm a squeeze, a familiar gesture that now felt strangely hollow. “And how’s my little artist doing? Show Mommy what you and Sarah made.”
Leo bounded over, proudly displaying his jungle scene. As he turned, his inner wrist was again briefly exposed. Brenda’s eyes flickered to it, just for a split second, then quickly moved on to the cardboard animals. It was barely perceptible, a micro-expression of something unreadable, but I saw it. I saw the tension in her jaw, the way her smile tightened around her eyes.
She knew.
She had to.
Later that evening, back in the quiet sanctuary of my own apartment, the birthmark burned in my memory. The casual, dismissive tone Brenda used when talking about her “wild cousin.” The way she quickly changed the subject if he was ever mentioned. It all clicked into place with a horrifying precision.
I opened my laptop, my fingers hovering over the search bar. This wasn’t about proving my sanity to myself anymore. This was about a child, a hidden truth, and a manipulation far deeper than I had ever imagined.
I started with a simple search: “David Sullivan Spring Lake.”
The first few results were generic, old news articles about local high school sports, a few forgotten social media profiles from over a decade ago. But then I found a link to a faded local newspaper archive. It mentioned a “minor incident” at a community event, involving “local youth David Sullivan,” though the details were scant. The date listed, however, caught my eye: roughly nine years ago. That would make Leo around eight now.
My stomach twisted into a knot. This couldn’t be a coincidence. The birthmark, the age, the “wild cousin” who disappeared from plain view.
I dug deeper, cross-referencing names, looking for any mention of the Holloway family in connection to David Sullivan around that specific time. It felt like piecing together a puzzle with half the pieces missing, but the picture that was slowly forming was undeniably unsettling.
I scrolled through old Facebook posts, careful to avoid anything that would reveal my identity or connection to Brenda. I found a few more public mentions of David Sullivan, often in comments from older Spring Lake residents reminiscing about “the good old days” or “trouble at the old Miller place.” These comments, fragmented and sometimes contradictory, painted a picture of David as a restless, charming, but ultimately unreliable young man who had a brief, turbulent return to Spring Lake before vanishing again.
One comment, posted on a long-defunct community forum from almost a decade ago, stood out. It was a complaint about “young David Sullivan causing a scene at the town hall dance,” and in a later reply, another user mused, “Didn’t he and Brenda Holloway have a falling out around that time? Always seemed so close before.”
A falling out. Brenda and David. Around that time. The same time period that roughly coincided with Leo’s age.
My previous fears about my own sanity now seemed trivial in comparison to the implications of this new trail. The gaslighting wasn’t just random acts of cruelty. It was a carefully constructed smokescreen, meant to distract, to destabilize, to make anyone who questioned the perfect Holloway family seem unhinged. Brenda wasn’t trying to make me crazy for the fun of it. She was trying to prevent me from seeing *this*.
I closed my laptop, the screen reflecting my own tense, pale face. The Spring Lake air, usually so fresh and comforting, now felt thick with unspoken secrets. I had stumbled upon something profound, something dangerous, and Brenda Holloway, my “perfect friend,” was at the heart of it. I knew, with a chilling certainty, that I had to keep digging, no matter the cost. My previous fear was replaced by a grim determination.
+ There are no comments
Add yours