Chapter 3: A Brother’s Sympathy

#content-1

Mark Albright walked into my kitchen, a bouquet of lilies in one hand and a sympathetic smile on his face. He looked every inch the concerned older brother, dressed in a crisp suit, his expensive watch gleaming. Leo, who had been quietly drawing at the kitchen table, glanced up, then quickly returned to his paper.

“Sarah, how are you holding up?” he asked, his voice smooth, almost too gentle.

He placed the flowers in a vase I offered, his movements practiced and calm. His performance was flawless, completely at odds with the rage still simmering beneath my own composure. I pictured the voided insurance policy, then the $2.3 million payment, a secret burning in my gut.

“I’m managing, Mark,” I replied, my voice steady, betraying none of the turmoil within. “It’s been a lot to process.”

He leaned against the counter, crossing his arms. “I know, sis. This whole… seeing David… it’s really taken a toll. You need to take care of yourself.”

His eyes held a feigned concern, but I saw the subtle shift, the way he watched my hands. He was assessing me, looking for weakness, for any sign that I might be unraveling. It was a chilling performance.

“You really think I’m imagining things, don’t you?” I asked, my voice flat, testing him.

Mark sighed, a long, weary sound designed to convey regret. “It’s been three years, Sarah. Three years of grief, of trying to cope. It’s natural to… grasp at straws, to see things.”

“Grasp at straws?” I repeated, a dangerous edge creeping into my tone.

He quickly softened his expression. “I just mean, your mind could be playing tricks. David’s death was a tragedy, but it was confirmed. The authorities, the insurance company…”

“The insurance company that voided my policy but paid yours?” The words almost slipped out, but I caught them, a sharp intake of breath. I needed to play his game, for now.

He didn’t miss my pause. His eyes narrowed almost imperceptibly, a flicker of suspicion. “What did you say?”

“Nothing,” I said, forcing a smile that felt brittle on my lips. “Just… the paperwork. It’s been a lot.”

He relaxed slightly, but the tension in the room persisted. “Exactly. That’s why I’m here. I’ve been thinking about David’s old business papers. The real estate projects he was working on with me.”

He pushed off the counter, moving toward David’s old desk in the corner of the kitchen. “Maybe going through them, getting some finality, would help you find some peace.”

Peace. The word felt like a deliberate insult. He was offering me “peace” while sitting on a pile of money gained from David’s orchestrated disappearance. The blatant hypocrisy made my stomach churn.

“Why now, Mark?” I asked, watching him. “You never offered to help before.”

He chuckled, a light, dismissive sound. “Well, you seemed to be doing fine, pulling yourself back together. But now, with this… incident… it’s clear you’re still struggling. I just want to help my sister.”

His gaze swept over the desk, lingering on the stack of old ledgers David had kept. It was a subtle move, but I noticed it. He wasn’t interested in my peace; he was interested in something in those papers. Something David might have left behind.

“David was always so meticulous,” Mark continued, picking up a heavy binder. “He kept everything. Project timelines, appraisals, investor reports.”

He flipped through a few pages, his fingers tracing lines of numbers. It was a charade, a performance for my benefit, but it contained a kernel of truth. He *did* want to see those papers.

“I could sit with you for an afternoon, maybe later this week,” he offered, his tone magnanimous. “Just go through them. Tie up any loose ends. For David’s memory.”

For David’s memory. The phrase felt like a dagger. He was desecrating David’s memory with every lie, every manipulation. I almost laughed at the irony.

“That’s… very thoughtful of you, Mark,” I said, trying to gauge his true intentions. Could he be genuinely trying to find something he thought David had left? Or was he trying to clear his tracks?

My gut screamed that it was the latter. He wanted to control the narrative, to ensure no incriminating evidence survived. He probably assumed I wouldn’t understand the complex financial documents.

“It might bring you some peace, Sarah,” he repeated, emphasizing the word. “Knowing everything is handled. David would have wanted that.”

He gave me a reassuring smile, the kind he always used when he wanted something. I recognized it from countless family dinners, countless times he’d charmed his way into getting what he wanted. He always made it sound like *my* benefit, never his.

Leo, still at the table, dropped his crayon. The small, sharp sound echoed in the sudden quiet. He looked up, his young face pale, his eyes wide as they flitted between Mark and me. He was sensing the tension, the unspoken battle.

This was a petty cruelty in itself: Mark using David’s memory, his death, and my grief, as a tool for his own gain, all while presenting himself as a caring brother. He was casually dismantling the remnants of David’s life, and by extension, mine.

“I appreciate it, Mark,” I said, my voice carefully modulated. “How about tomorrow morning? We can go through them together.”

His smile widened, a flicker of triumph in his eyes before he masked it. “Perfect. I’ll clear my schedule.”

He genuinely believed he was winning, that he had me convinced of my own fragility. He thought he was about to tie up a loose end. He thought he was coming to inspect the scene, to ensure everything was clean.

But he was wrong. I would be watching him, scrutinizing every move. He had no idea what I now knew. I would use his offer, his false sympathy, as my own opportunity. The game had just begun.

You May Also Like

More From Author

+ There are no comments

Add yours