Dr. Finch’s accidental slip had given me a target. I spent the next few days in a haze of caffeine and internet searches. I couldn’t ask Dr. Finch directly for details about his former patient; patient confidentiality was paramount. But I could search for unusual local incidents, reports of strange behaviors, anything that might align with a “whispering pond” or a parent’s desperate acts.
The more I searched, the more frustrated I became. Public records were sparse. News archives yielded nothing about a specific case that matched. It was like chasing a ghost. I felt the weight of my isolation grow heavier with each dead end.
My lawyer, Mr. Davison, was pushing for an expedited hearing based on Lily’s trauma. He didn’t understand my sudden, almost obsessive, dive into what he called “conspiracy theories.”
“Arthur,” he’d said on the phone.
“We need to focus on established legal grounds. Lily’s testimony, the obvious neglect.”
“But if we understand *why* Victor did it, it changes everything,” I argued.
“Not legally,” he countered, his voice firm.
“It might explain motive, but it doesn’t excuse caging a child.”
“No, but it might explain *what* he was trying to protect her from,” I insisted.
He sighed heavily.
“Please, Arthur. Let me handle the law. You focus on Lily.”
I knew he was right, in a conventional sense. But the conventional sense was proving useless against the truth of what I had seen. Lily was improving, slowly. She would sometimes draw pictures of a dark pool with strange, glowing shapes in it, always with a small figure — her — standing far away. She still hummed the soft, melancholic tune she called the “water’s song.”
Then, the anonymous email arrived. It was terse, no subject line, just a few sentences: “Regarding Victor Kincaid. Be careful. He has a history. Look into the ‘thin spots.’ He used to talk about an abyssal echo and our cat. Hayes.”
Hayes. It was a name I didn’t recognize immediately. But “thin spots” and “abyssal echo” – those terms resonated with a primal fear. This was it. This was the lead I needed. I immediately searched for “Victor Kincaid Hayes.”
A few clicks later, I found it: a property record from six years ago, listing Victor Kincaid and a Sylvia Hayes as co-owners of a small cottage just forty miles north of here. The property had been sold quickly, at a loss, within a year of purchase. My hand trembled as I typed Sylvia Hayes’s name into a search engine. I found a public profile, an old photo of a kind-faced woman with tired eyes.
I debated for hours whether to contact her. What if she was another one of Victor’s victims, afraid to speak? What if she dismissed me as crazy, just like everyone else? But the email felt too urgent, too specific to ignore. This woman knew something.
I crafted a careful email, identifying myself as Lily’s father and explaining, briefly, my concerns about Victor and the pool. I mentioned the phrase “abyssal echo” from her anonymous note. I sent it, then sat by my phone, the minutes stretching into an eternity.
The call came two hours later. The caller ID was blocked.
“Mr. Sterling?” a woman’s voice asked, low and hesitant.
“This is Sylvia Hayes.”
Her voice was tight with fear, but also a hidden urgency.
“Thank you for contacting me,” I said, trying to keep my voice steady.
“I received your email.”
“I know,” she replied.
“I didn’t want to get involved, but… I saw the news. About Lily.”
“You knew Victor,” I stated, making it a question.
“For almost five years,” she confirmed, her voice cracking.
“Before… before he met Theresa.”
“Your email mentioned ‘thin spots’,” I prompted.
“And an ‘abyssal echo’.”
There was a long silence on the other end, then a shaky sigh.
“He was always… intense,” Sylvia began, her voice a little stronger now.
“Obsessed with strange things. Old books, local legends.”
“He collected stories about ‘thin spots’ where worlds overlapped.”
“He believed our old cottage… that it was one of them.”
My blood ran cold. This was exactly what I’d been looking for.
“What did he believe was there?” I asked, my grip tightening on the phone.
“He called it the ‘abyssal echo’,” she whispered, the words filled with lingering terror.
“He said it was a presence, trying to manifest. Feeding on… negative emotions. Fear.”
“Did you ever… see anything?” I ventured carefully.
“At first, no,” she said, her voice laced with regret.
“He just talked. Obsessively. It started after our cat, Mittens, disappeared.”
“He was convinced the ‘echo’ had tried to ‘claim’ her.”
A wave of nausea hit me. Claim her. Just like Lily had described the whispers of the pool trying to claim her.
“He started performing… rituals,” Sylvia continued, her voice trembling.
“Leaving strange offerings around the property. He said it was to keep the echo from getting strong enough to cross over.”
“Offerings?” I asked.
“What kind of offerings?”
“Just… things,” she said vaguely.
“Dead birds sometimes, things he’d found. Things that were… decaying.”
“He became paranoid. Boarding up windows, digging strange trenches.”
“He thought the entity was trying to get in through the plumbing, through the water.”
My mind flashed to Victor’s pool, the black sacs he was extracting. He thought he was containing it, perhaps feeding it its own discarded manifestations to keep it from claiming something else.
“Did he ever… build a cage?” I asked, the words feeling ridiculous even as I said them.
Sylvia let out a choked laugh, full of bitter irony.
“Not a cage, no. But he built a structure. A small, reinforced shed near the well.”
“He called it his ‘containment unit’.”
“He would spend hours in there, sometimes days, convinced he was performing some vital task.”
“He said he was keeping the ‘weak points’ secure.”
“He said that if it ever got through, it would take everything we held dear.”
“Why did you leave him?” I asked, already guessing the answer.
“I couldn’t live with the fear anymore,” she confessed.
“He became consumed. I tried to get him help. He refused. He said I was ‘blind’ to the truth.”
“He said the echo was real, and it was protecting us.”
“I thought he was having a breakdown,” she admitted.
“A psychotic break. I reported him. But without any direct harm, they just… monitored him.”
“I eventually had to get a restraining order and sell my share of the property.”
“I just wanted to forget it all.”
“Why come forward now?” I pressed.
“You said you saw the news about Lily.”
“Yes,” she said, her voice heavy with guilt.
“When I heard about the cage, and the pool… I knew. It wasn’t just a breakdown.”
“Or maybe it was, but he was acting on something he genuinely believed.”
“And he was doing it again.”
“He told me, once, that the echo could be… lured,” she continued, her voice barely a whisper.
“Or appeased. He said it promised things. Terrible things, but also… tempting things.”
“What kind of tempting things?” I asked, my heart hammering.
“He never specified,” she replied.
“Just that it spoke to him. Promised him what he most desired.”
A cold sweat broke out on my forehead. This was more than a pattern of delusion. This was a direct, chilling link. Victor’s actions were not random acts of cruelty but part of a long-standing, twisted belief system, fueled by fear and some insidious, unseen entity. The “abyssal echo” was not just a phrase; it was a terrifying presence that followed him.
“Thank you, Sylvia,” I said, my voice thick with emotion.
“You have no idea what this means.”
“Just… be careful, Arthur,” she warned.
“Victor is a desperate man. And what he believes in… it’s powerful.”
The call ended, leaving me in stunned silence. Sylvia Hayes’s story confirmed everything. Victor wasn’t a sadist; he was a terrified, deluded man trying to fight a threat he believed was real. His actions, from the “containment unit” to the “offerings,” mirrored his current behavior perfectly. The cage, the sacs, the pool’s whispers – they were all part of a dark, ongoing battle Victor had been fighting for years.
I felt a profound shift in my understanding. My anger at Victor was still there, but now it was tinged with a new, terrifying sympathy. He was a man consumed by fear, a puppet of something ancient and malevolent. But this also meant the entity itself was real, and it was capable of influencing human minds.
I looked at the notes I’d scrawled during the call: “thin spots,” “abyssal echo,” “promises,” “cat.” It painted a picture of a man desperately trying to protect his family from an invisible enemy, but in the most horrifying and misguided ways. And now, Lily was caught in its grasp.
I pulled out my phone again, my fingers flying across the screen. I had to confront Theresa. She had to know about Victor’s past. She had to see the terrifying pattern that was now undeniable. My next step was clear: armed with this chilling history, I would force her to face the truth. The echoes from Victor’s former life had just slammed into our present.
+ There are no comments
Add yours