The confrontation with Theresa was inevitable. Armed with Sylvia’s testimony and the unsettling details from Dr. Finch, I felt a grim resolve settle over me. This wasn’t just a custody battle; it was a fight for Lily’s sanity, perhaps even her soul.
I arranged to meet Theresa at a neutral location – a quiet cafe, far from their house and the haunting presence of the pool. She arrived looking haggard, her usual carefully applied makeup unable to conceal the dark circles under her eyes. She wore a forced smile that didn’t reach her eyes.
“Arthur,” she began, her voice a little too bright.
“Lily is doing better, isn’t she? Dr. Finch said…”
“Dr. Finch said Lily is traumatized,” I cut in, my voice devoid of warmth.
“And he shared a detail that ties directly to Victor’s past.”
Her smile faltered. She picked up her coffee cup, her hands trembling slightly.
“What are you talking about?”
“I’m talking about Victor’s obsession with ‘thin spots’,” I stated, pushing a small folder across the table towards her.
“His belief in an ‘abyssal echo’ that follows him.”
She glanced at the folder, her eyes wide with a flicker of fear.
“I don’t know what you mean.”
“Oh, I think you do,” I countered, my voice low and dangerous.
“Do you know a Sylvia Hayes?”
The color drained from her face. She closed her eyes for a moment, then reopened them, looking directly at me.
“She’s his ex-partner,” she whispered.
“She said he was… disturbed.”
“Disturbed enough to try and ‘contain’ an entity he believed was trying to ‘claim’ their cat,” I pressed.
“He built a ‘containment unit’ for it. He left ‘offerings’.”
Her jaw tightened.
“Arthur, he… he had some strange ideas. I thought they were just stories.”
“Just stories?” I scoffed.
“He locked our daughter in a dog cage, Theresa. He believes the pool is singing to her. He’s been pulling strange, glowing, pulsating sacs out of that water.”
“You know this is a pattern of behavior.”
“He told me it was to protect us,” she insisted, her voice rising slightly.
“That Lily was too sensitive, that she was drawing something to her.”
“He told you because you believed him,” I accused, my voice sharp.
“You allowed this to happen.”
She recoiled as if struck.
“I didn’t! I didn’t believe him at first, Arthur, I swear!”
Her carefully composed façade shattered. Tears welled up in her eyes, carving tracks through her makeup.
“I thought he was just… eccentric.”
“But then… one night.”
Her voice dropped to a terrified whisper.
“It was after he started messing with the pool. He was trying to drain it, then fill it with… with certain salts.”
“I went out there, angry.”
“I told him he was being ridiculous. That he was scaring Lily.”
“What happened?” I urged, leaning forward, every fiber of my being focused on her.
“The water,” she choked out.
“It turned violently black. Not just murky, Arthur. Black like… like ink.”
“And it started to churn.”
Her hands flew up to cover her mouth, her eyes wide with remembered terror.
“A shadow. A form. It rose from the depths.”
“It reached for me.”
“It tried to drag me under.”
A cold wave washed over me. This wasn’t Victor’s delusion. This was *her* experience. She had seen it too. She had felt its touch.
“It was cold,” she whispered, tears streaming freely now.
“So cold. And it felt like… like pure emptiness. Like it was trying to consume me whole.”
“Victor… he pulled me back.”
“He shouted at it. Threw things into the pool. I don’t know what.”
“He saved me.”
She looked at me, her eyes pleading for understanding.
“He said it was the abyssal echo. He said it was angry because he was trying to keep it from Lily.”
“He said it had been promising her things. Trying to lure her.”
“Promising her what?” I asked, a fresh wave of dread washing over me.
“He wouldn’t say,” Theresa sobbed.
“He just said it knew what she wanted most. What she had lost.”
My mind raced. Lily’s twin brother, Leo, had died at birth. It was a pain that had always shadowed Theresa, and by extension, Lily. Could the entity be exploiting that deep, unhealed wound?
“And after that, you believed him,” I stated, not a question.
She nodded, burying her face in her hands.
“What else could I do, Arthur? I saw it with my own eyes.”
“He said he had to protect us. That the cage was the only way to keep Lily safe from its whispers.”
“He said he was trying to appease it, keep it from getting stronger.”
“He said he was fighting for our family.”
Her confession hung heavy in the air. Theresa wasn’t just complicit out of denial; she was complicit out of sheer, unadulterated terror. She had witnessed the entity. She had been physically targeted by it. And in her fear, she had placed all her trust, and Lily’s safety, in Victor’s twisted methods.
“Why didn’t you tell anyone?” I asked, my voice raw.
“Who would believe me?” she cried, looking up, her face streaked with tears.
“They’d say I was crazy. They’d take Lily away. They’d say Victor was a monster, which… which he is, in his own way.”
“But he was trying to save us, Arthur!”
“He believed it!”
“He truly believed he was protecting us from something worse!”
“So you let him lock her in a cage?” I demanded, my anger flaring despite the chilling revelations.
“You let him expose her to those… things in the pool?”
“I… I didn’t know what else to do,” she stammered, shrinking back.
“He was so certain. So desperate. I was terrified.”
“I was frozen with fear, Arthur. Don’t you understand?”
“He told me that if the echo ever crossed over completely, it would destroy us all.”
“He said it would take more than just Lily.”
“And that he had to be the one to stop it.”
The full weight of Theresa’s complicity, born of fear, settled on me. She wasn’t malicious, but deeply, tragically terrified and misguided. She had traded Lily’s immediate safety for a desperate hope that Victor could somehow contain an uncontainable evil.
“This changes nothing about the custody,” I said, my voice firm.
“But it changes everything about what we’re up against.”
She just nodded, staring blankly ahead. She looked utterly broken. Her silence, her fear, her terrible choice—it had all led to this. The truth was out, not just about Victor, but about the very real, terrifying threat he believed he was fighting. And now, armed with this complete picture, I knew the real battle was only just beginning.
This wasn’t just a legal fight anymore. It was a fight against an ancient, insidious entity that had already claimed a piece of Victor’s mind and nearly dragged Theresa into its depths. And it was still whispering to Lily.
+ There are no comments
Add yours